Home / Template

A Collector's & Hunter's Guide to the Model 10, 17, and 37 Shotguns

Status: Available (419 KB) Download

As a lifelong hunter and outdoor enthusiast, I’ve always been fascinated by the evolution of firearms. Among the most iconic and historically significant shotguns ever produced in the United States are the Remington Model 10, the Remington Model 17 (often sought after as a 17 gauge shotgun), and the Ithaca Model 37. These firearms aren’t just tools; they represent eras of American sporting arms design and even played roles in significant historical events, including the Second World War. This guide will delve into the history, variations, and practical considerations for anyone interested in these classic shotguns, whether you're a collector, a hunter, or simply curious about their legacy. Understanding the nuances of the model 10 shotgun, its contemporaries, and their place in firearms history is a rewarding pursuit.

The Remington Model 10: A Pioneering Pump-Action

The Remington Model 10, introduced in 1913, was a groundbreaking shotgun. It was Remington’s first successful pump-action shotgun, and it quickly gained popularity for its reliability and affordability. It was a direct competitor to the Winchester Model 12, and the two shotguns dominated the pump-action market for decades. The Model 10 was chambered in 12 and 16 gauge, and featured a smooth action and a solid build. Early models are particularly sought after by collectors.

Key Features of the Remington Model 10

  • Action Type: Pump-action, bottom eject
  • Gauge: 12 and 16 gauge
  • Choke: Fixed, typically Full or Modified
  • Receiver: Black steel
  • Stock & Forend: Walnut

The Model 10 saw service in various roles, from hunting to law enforcement. While not as widely adopted by the military as some other shotguns, its robust design made it a dependable firearm. Finding a well-maintained Model 10 today is a treat for any shotgun enthusiast. Remington continues to produce firearms, though the Model 10 is no longer in production.

The Remington Model 17: The Elegant 17 Gauge

The Remington Model 17, introduced in 1935, is a bit of a niche firearm. It was specifically designed and chambered for the 17 gauge, a gauge that never achieved the widespread popularity of 12 or 20 gauge. However, those who appreciate the 17 gauge – and there are many – swear by its balance of power and reduced recoil. The Model 17 was available in both pump-action and semi-automatic versions. The pump-action version, closely related to the Model 10, is more common. The semi-automatic version, while rarer, is highly prized by collectors.

Why the 17 Gauge?

The 17 gauge offers a unique shooting experience. It delivers more energy than a 20 gauge but with less recoil than a 12 gauge. This makes it ideal for upland bird hunting, particularly for those sensitive to recoil. However, the limited availability of ammunition can be a drawback. Shooters Forum has extensive discussions on the Model 17 and 17 gauge ammunition.

The Ithaca Model 37: A Legend in Shotgun Design

The Ithaca Model 37, introduced in 1937, is arguably the most significant shotgun on this list. It was the first commercially successful gas-operated autoloading shotgun, a design that revolutionized the industry. The Model 37 is renowned for its reliability, durability, and smooth action. It was chambered in 12, 16, 20, and 28 gauge, and saw extensive use during World War II. The Ithaca shotgun WW2 models are particularly collectible, having been used by the US military.

The Model 37 in Wartime: A Shot Gun War Story

During World War II, the Ithaca Model 37 was adopted by the US military as the Model 37 Trench Gun. These shotguns were equipped with a bayonet lug and a longer barrel, and were used extensively in the Pacific Theater. The Model 37 proved to be incredibly effective in close-quarters combat, and its reputation for reliability cemented its place in military history. The model 37 shotgun ww2 variants are highly sought after by collectors, often commanding premium prices. The National Park Service provides detailed information on the WWII homefront and military history.

Ithaca Model 37 Variations

  • Standard Field Grade: The most common version, suitable for hunting and sporting clays.
  • Skeet Grade: Designed for skeet shooting, with a lighter trigger pull and a more open choke.
  • Trap Grade: Designed for trap shooting, with a heavier barrel and a more open choke.
  • Deerstalker: A specialized version with a rifled barrel for deer hunting.
  • Military Model (WWII): Equipped with a bayonet lug and a longer barrel.

Comparing the Three Shotguns

Feature Remington Model 10 Remington Model 17 Ithaca Model 37
Action Type Pump-Action Pump-Action & Semi-Auto Gas-Operated Autoloading
Gauge 12 & 16 17 12, 16, 20, 28
Historical Significance First Remington Pump-Action Unique 17 Gauge Offering First Successful Gas-Operated Autoloader, WWII Service
Collector Value Moderate High (especially semi-auto) High (especially WWII models)

Condition and Value: What to Look For

When considering purchasing any of these shotguns, condition is paramount. Here are some key things to look for:

  1. Bluing: Check for wear and tear on the bluing. Original bluing in good condition significantly increases value.
  2. Wood: Inspect the stock and forend for cracks, dents, and scratches. Original wood is preferable.
  3. Action: Ensure the action functions smoothly and reliably.
  4. Bore: Check the bore for pitting or damage. A clean, shiny bore is essential.
  5. Originality: Original parts and markings add to the value.

Values can vary widely depending on condition, gauge, and specific features. A well-preserved Ithaca Model 37 Trench Gun can easily fetch several thousand dollars, while a Remington Model 10 in good condition might sell for around $500-$800. The 17 gauge shotgun Model 17, particularly the semi-automatic version, can also command high prices due to its rarity. Consult with a qualified firearms appraiser for an accurate valuation.

Responsible Ownership and Safety

Owning a classic firearm comes with a responsibility to practice safe gun handling and adhere to all applicable laws. Always follow the four rules of gun safety: The NRA provides excellent resources on firearm safety. Furthermore, be aware of local and state regulations regarding ownership, storage, and transportation of firearms. Proper maintenance and storage are crucial to preserving these historical firearms for future generations.

Resources for Further Research

  • National Rifle Association (NRA)
  • Remington
  • Ithaca Gun Company
  • GunsAmerica (for current market values)
  • Field & Stream (for hunting and shooting information)

In conclusion, the Remington Model 10, Model 17, and Ithaca Model 37 represent a golden age of American shotgun design. Whether you're a collector, a hunter, or a history buff, these firearms offer a fascinating glimpse into the past. By understanding their history, variations, and proper care, you can appreciate these iconic shotguns for years to come. Remember to always prioritize safety and responsible ownership.